Stock Analiz

Best insurance stocks

Updated November 16, 2026

We cover 120 US-listed insurance companies. The largest is Berkshire Hathaway Inc. (BRK-B), worth $1.31T. These are the 20 with the highest analysis scores today.

How we pick: Insurance stocks with a market cap above $2 billion, ranked by overall score from 0 to 5 (the average of value, future, past, financial health and shareholder returns), then by size.
#CompanyMarket capUpside to fair valueDividendScore
1White Mountains Insurance Group Ltd.WTM$5.4B+179%0.0%4.4
2Kinsale Capital Group, Inc.KNSL$9.0B-68%0.2%3.8
3Primerica, Inc.PRI$8.9B+24%1.6%3.8
4NMI Holdings, Inc.NMIH$2.9B+34%—3.8
5Progressive Corp.PGR$137.5B-44%0.2%3.6
6Hartford Insurance Group, Inc.HIG$36.7B+44%1.9%3.6
7Globe Life Inc.GL$12.0B+22%0.8%3.6
8Old Republic International Corp.ORI$9.6B+145%3.2%3.6
9First American Financial CorpFAF$6.7B+10%3.8%3.6
10HCI Group, Inc.HCI$2.4B-54%0.8%3.6
11Travelers Companies, Inc.TRV$82.5B-67%1.2%3.4
12Arch Capital Group Ltd.ACGL$36.0B-60%—3.4
13Reinsurance Group OF America Inc.RGA$17.7B-29%1.4%3.4
14Jackson Financial Inc.JXN$9.0B+112%2.6%3.4
15Hanover Insurance Group, Inc.THG$8.6B-55%1.5%3.4
16Essent Group Ltd.ESNT$5.7B+1%2.2%3.4
17Radian Group Inc.RDN$4.7B+123%2.8%3.4
18Aon plcAON$72.7B+7%1.0%3.2
19Allstate Corp.ALL$66.9B-37%1.6%3.2
20Cincinnati Financial Corp.CINF$29.4B-64%2.0%3.2

A closer look at the top three

White Mountains Insurance Group Ltd. (WTM): It has revenue growth of 48% a year over three years, an average net margin of 21%, a P/E of about 6, an intrinsic value about 179% above the current price and an overall score of 4.4 out of 5 (strong company).

Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. (KNSL): It has revenue growth of 31% a year over three years, an average net margin of 26%, a P/E of about 17, an intrinsic value about 68% below the current price and an overall score of 3.8 out of 5 (good, with some weak spots).

Primerica, Inc. (PRI): It has revenue growth of 7% a year over three years, an average net margin of 20%, a P/E of about 12, an intrinsic value about 24% above the current price and an overall score of 3.8 out of 5 (good, with some weak spots).

Frequently asked questions

What is the best insurance stock right now?

By today’s analysis score, White Mountains Insurance Group Ltd. (WTM) ranks first with 4.4 out of 5. A score is one measure and does not replace a full analysis.

How many insurance stocks are listed in the US?

Our data covers 120 insurance companies, each with its own analysis page.

How is the 0–5 score calculated?

Each stock faces five numeric tests in each of five areas (value, future, past, financial health and shareholder returns); the overall score is the average of the five.

More lists and tools

Lists are generated automatically from SEC filings and market prices and rebuilt every day. They are a starting point for research, not a recommendation to buy or sell.